Updated September 6, 2026. Denville argues about pizza the way every North Jersey town argues about pizza, except Denville has enough of it to make the argument interesting. There are pizzerias on Broadway, on East Main Street, on Bloomfield Avenue and on Diamond Spring Road, plus two sit down Italian rooms that are not pizzerias at all. This is the Denville Now guide to where to get a slice or a pie in town, kept current as places open and close.
Downtown Denville
- Dante’s of Denville, 29 Broadway, (973) 627-9777. The Broadway pizzeria, doing hand tossed New York style pies and an Italian kitchen menu. Closest pizza to the train station and the Bloomfield Avenue lot.
- Sergio and Co. Italian Specialties, 28 Broadway, (973) 627-1043. Not a pizzeria, but worth knowing about. Open since 1999, and the source of the hero trays and homemade Italian specialties that show up at half the parties in Morris County.
East Main Street
- Casa D’Pizza, 276 East Main Street, (973) 784-4710. Wood burning oven pizzeria and restaurant, and the name that comes up most often when Denville people are asked for a specialty pie rather than a plain slice.
- Jimmy Tomato’s Pizzeria, 123 East Main Street, (973) 627-2453. Family run counter service pizzeria. The same kitchen also runs a Bombay Curry Pizza menu, so the curry pies and the classic pies come from one address.
- Suppa’s Ristorante and Pizzeria, 490 East Main Street, (973) 453-6874. A sit down Italian restaurant with a pizzeria attached, on the East Main strip.
- That’s Amore Trattoria, 366 East Main Street, (973) 586-8856. Small trattoria doing pizza alongside homemade Italian. Dinner service, and it keeps limited days, so call before you drive over.
Bloomfield Avenue and Diamond Spring Road
- il Torrente Pizza, 101 Bloomfield Avenue, (973) 957-0600. Neighborhood pizzeria on Bloomfield with daily lunch specials, a few minutes from the farmers market lot.
- Kraves Pizza and Restaurant, 28 Diamond Spring Road, (973) 453-6655. Pizza plus a full Italian restaurant menu, and a regular in the running whenever Denville argues about its best pizza. It sits in the Diamond Spring plaza alongside Thonglor Thai Bistro.
Sit down Italian, no pizza counter
- Casa Bella, 300 Route 46, (973) 627-2003. The dressed up Italian dinner in Denville. The dining room is the formal option in town, and in warm weather the deck over Arrowhead Lake is one of the best outdoor tables anywhere in the township.
Recently closed
- Denville Pizzeria, 20 Diamond Spring Road. Closed in late August 2026 after roughly 50 years in business. Its pages are still live on the delivery apps, so it is easy to place an order with a shop that is no longer there. Do not.
Frequently asked questions about pizza in Denville
How many pizzerias are in Denville, NJ?
Six are currently open: Dante’s of Denville on Broadway, Casa D’Pizza, Jimmy Tomato’s and Suppa’s on East Main Street, il Torrente on Bloomfield Avenue and Kraves on Diamond Spring Road. That’s Amore Trattoria also serves pizza. Denville Pizzeria on Diamond Spring Road closed in August 2026.
Where is the closest pizza to the Denville train station?
Dante’s of Denville at 29 Broadway. It is a short walk from the NJ Transit Denville platform and the Bloomfield Avenue municipal lot, which makes it the practical stop on the way home from the city.
Which Denville pizzeria has a wood burning oven?
Casa D’Pizza at 276 East Main Street.
Where do you get sit down Italian in Denville?
Casa Bella at 300 Route 46 for a real dinner out, Suppa’s at 490 East Main Street and Kraves at 28 Diamond Spring Road for a full Italian menu with a pizzeria attached, and That’s Amore Trattoria at 366 East Main Street for something smaller.
Is there Italian takeout in Denville that is not pizza?
Sergio and Co. at 28 Broadway, open since 1999, does heroes, homemade Italian specialties and the catering trays. It is a specialty shop rather than a restaurant.
Opened, closed or changed hands? Tell us and we will update this guide. For everywhere else to eat in town see our guides to Denville restaurants and Chinese food in Denville, and for what is going on around town see things to do in Denville.
